Have you been considering using negative thought stopping exercises and techniques to quieten your mind? If so, you might be wondering, “do negative thought stopping exercises and techniques work?”

In my experience as a meditation teacher, the more I try to forcefully stop my thoughts the worse they get. I find it impossible to completely stop thoughts. While we might want to remove intrusive thoughts and recurring negative thoughts, we cannot simply delete them.

It might seem like a good idea to stop negative thoughts, especially if you’ve been suffering from stress and anxiety. Thought stopping seems like a good choice because you no longer want to experience thoughts that cause you pain. Problematic thoughts, such as catastrophic thinking, can cause mental health problems like anxiety and depression. 

Certainly there are some  powerful techniques for stopping negative thoughts.

But what is better than stopping negative thoughts is simply changing negative thoughts to more positive ones. Let me show you why thought stopping exercises are a bad idea.

Let’s take a look at what negative thoughts stopping exercises are. Then I’ll explain why they are a bad idea and I will share some better options with you. 

What Are Negative Thought Stopping Exercises 

Negative thought stopping exercises and techniques are essentially the idea of completely preventing any painful thoughts from occurring [READ: 11 brutal types of negative thoughts].

However, you might wonder whether thought stopping works.

There are actually times when thoughts do literally stop. This is called “Mind Blanking”. Research conducted by Adrian F. Ward and Daniel M. Wegner and published in Frontiers In Psychology reveals that “when the mind seems to disappear, there are times when we have simply failed to monitor its whereabouts—and there are times when it is actually gone.” [1]. You have probably experienced this. I know that I myself often have moments when I realise my mind has been gone somewhere although I m not sure where. This is called “Mind Blanking”. However, for most people, “thought stopping” means interrupting thoughts that cause pain.

The most basic example of a thought stopping is when we literally tell the mind to “Stop! This is one way of dealing with negative thoughts that cause you emotional pain. There is conflicting research about such techniques. Some research suggests that thought stopping techniques can be beneficial. Other research shows that stopping negative thoughts actually makes them resurface later on and in worse ways.  

Scientific research shows that when we try to stop negative thoughts, we actually just make the thought come up later, and often worse than it was to begin with. Research by Wegner, D. M. at Harvard University [2] shows that when we try to stop thinking negative thoughts we actually cause the them to crop up again later. Not only this, but it actually causes an increase in feelings of anxiety and depression.

Thought-stopping-exercises have been undermined as a psychological exercise. It is generally agreed that attempting to stop your negative thoughts is a universally bad idea. But why?  

Think about the Pink Elephant

Imagine a big pink elephant in your mind. Visualize it clearly. Force yourself to stop thinking about the elephant for ten minutes   After ten minutes of suppressing the thought, notice how you cannot help but think about the elephant. Thought suppression actually causes you to think the thought more, not less. And that is why thought-stopping-exercises simply do not work. And that means that when you do experience a negative thoughts, stop trying to prevent the thought and actually pay attention to it. 

While some positive thinking exercises do work, negative thought stopping exercises do not.  In fact, rather than helping us, thought stopping exercises will actually harm us. Attempting to silence those mental ruminations will actually just cause them to rise up again and again.

I know from my own experience that when I try to just end negative thoughts they simply get louder and more intrusive. Putting up psychological barriers does not work for me and actually makes my situations worse. I find it more effective when I work with my mind instead. And it seems science agrees with this. Robert L. Leahy Ph.D. states that “thought-stopping leads to thought rebounding.” [3]

Dave Carbonell, PhD agrees. He tells us that you will never stop negative thoughts by simply holding up a big red “STOP” sign to them, he says, “Worry and other forms of unwanted thoughts are like a heckler, rather than a mugger. You’ll be better off working with them than against them.” [4].   

So if negative thought stopping exercises do not work, what does?

Get the Personalised Meditation Experience (2)

5 Techniques That Are Better Than Negative Thought Stopping Exercises

 The following exercises are all based on Cognitive Behavioural Therapy, a psycho-social intervention that aims to improve mental health 

 

1. See negative thoughts for what they truly are

Instead of using negative thought-stopping exercises, learn to see your negative thoughts for what they truly are. The best way to do this is to practice Buddhist vipassana meditation.

Vipassana meditation technique is an exercise in which we label our different ideas and imaginings as they run through our minds. For instance, if we see a visual idea of something bad happening, we simply label it “visual”.

This simple exercise stops thoughts from having such a big impact on us. It does this by simply reminding us that thinks in our minds are only in our minds.

Too often we see thoughts as absolutes. We get lost in our imaginings and forget that they are not real. By simply saying to ourselves, “This is a thought”, we remind ourselves that our thoughts are not real. Then they have less of an emotional impact on us.

Here’s how to do it:

  1. Sit on a chair somewhere quiet and comfortable. Make sure your feet are shoulder-width apart and that your spine is in good alignment. Tuck your chin in a little to elongate your neck. 
  2. Close your eyes and focus on your breathing. Continue to breathe mindfully for ten minutes. 
  3. You will notice that intrusive thoughts enter your mind. And you might feel inclined to forcefully try and stop them. But the more you try and stop them the worse they will get. Instead, mindfully observe your thought. Now describe the thought to yourself. For instance, if you see a mental image, say to yourself, “This is just an image in my mind and is not real.”
  4. This process (called Vipassana Meditation) trains the mind to see thoughts more clearly, to realise that they are just thoughts and are not real. This makes us less reactive to negative thoughts.

 

2. Imagine it happening and ask “What then”

One of the biggest problems with so called “Thought stopping exercises” is that they train the mind to think of a negative thought as an absolute “No.”

If you stop negative thoughts, you prevent your mind from seeing past them. This creates almost a void, because your mind does not know where to go after it encounters that negative idea.

Rather than using thought stopping exercises, ask “If the worst thing happens, what happens next?”

For instance, let’s say you’re terrified your marriage is heading to the divorce court. You try using thought stopping exercises to prevent yourself from thinking about it. But the those ideas keep ruminating. Ask yourself, “What then?” What if you do break up? You will go through pain, recover, and move on, and before long the time will come when you are okay again.

By continuing the thought in this way, you teach your mind that the negative thought is not an absolute, and that even if the worst happens life will still go on.

 

 

3. Remind yourself of all the things that are preventing it from happening

When we focus on simply stopping thoughts, we prevent ourselves from logical reasoning. Instead of using thought stopping exercises, challenge those painful ruminations with some rational logic. Ask yourself both why the negative thought could happen and why it won’t happen

For instance, let’s say you’re worried about losing your job because you’ve been performing badly recently. Ask yourself why you could lose your job, and list the reasons (I’m performing badly / my results are declining / I don’t know how to fix the problem). This gives you valuable information that you can use to solve the problem. Now ask yourself why it wont happen (because I’m working on improving my performance / because I have great ideas / because I’m going to put in overtime to make sure I hit my targets).

By acknowledging both sides of the argument, you give yourself valuable insights that can help you to work around a possible negative event, and you also exercise your mind in thinking rationally about stressful events.

 

4. Learn the lesson

Too often a negative thought simply needs to be acknowledged. Ironically, this is precisely what thought stopping exercises prevent you from doing. When you try to stop them, you prevent yourself from acknowledging it. 

Instead of blocking the thought, ask yourself, “What is the lesson in this thought, and how do I act on it?”

For instance, let’s say you are experiencing painful thoughts about money. You’re worried you’re going to go broke and fail to pay the rent. You could block this thought, in which case you will learn nothing from it. Or you could ask yourself, “What is this thought teaching me? And how do I act on it?” Then you can see that the thought is teaching you to be more careful with money, and you can act on it by not going to the casino.

 

 

5. Imagine the worst

One of the reasons why thoughts cause pain is we do not accept them. Buddha taught that acceptance is the key to happiness. On way to accept thoughts is to imagine the absolute worst that could possibly happen and then imagine getting through it.

“Picturing yourself tackling the imagined worst possibility often gives us confidence that even if the worst were to happen, we would still be able to handle it.”

 

It’s time to stop using negative thought-stopping exercises for good

Negative thought Stopping Exercises will do you more harm than good. Because ultimately, painful thoughts exist for a reason, and they demand to be acknowledged.

Instead of stopping those painful ideas in your mind, exercise your rational mind. Learn to see those thoughts for what they are and what they represent.

What can you learn from that negativity? How are those negative thoughts helping you. And how can you use see them for the better?

Leave a comment, and remember to subscribe .

 

 

SOURCES:

1: Mind Blanks: When The Mind Goes Away, Adrian F. Ward and Daniel M. Wegner, Frontiers In Psychology, https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3784796/

2: Daniel Wegner, Wikipedia,  https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Daniel_Wegner

3:  Why Thought Stopping Doesn’t Work, Robert L. Leahy Ph.D., https://www.psychologytoday.com/ca/blog/anxiety-files/201007/why-thought-stopping-doesn-t-work

4: Thought Stopping: It Makes Worry Worse, Dave Carbonell, PhD, https://www.anxietycoach.com/thought-stopping.html

5: 7 Effective Thought-Stopping Techniques for Anxiety,  Tall Space, Melissa Stanger [licensed therapist]  https://www.talkspace.com/blog/anxiety-thought-stopping-techniques/

Written by Paul Harrison

Paul Harrison is a qualified meditation teacher and writer with more than 15 years experience in meditation and mindfulness. He studied meditation in Oxford, UK, and Hamilton Ontario Canada, and earned his degree at Staffordshire University. Paul has helped thousands of people to discover their true potential through mindfulness, yoga and meditation.



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *